Thursday, December 9, 2010

Asian Defense News: Lee Kuan Yew is Responsible for Creating a Vibrant and Dynamic Singapore Today

Thursday, 09 December 2010
Asian Defense News: John Kampfner, former editor of The New Statesman (2005-2008) and now chief executive of Index on Censorship, a British group promoting freedom of expression, weighed in on the Alan Shadrake case. He wrote a commentary in The Guardian after the 76-year-old freelance British journalist was found guilty of contempt of court over his book, Once a Jolly Hangman: Singapore’s Justice in the Dock.

Singapore's Senior Minister Lee Kuan Yew (L), former prime minister and architect of modern Singapore, his wife Kwa  Geok Choo (2nd L), his son Lee Hsien Loong (3rd L) and his daughter-in-law Ho Ching celebrate his 80th birthday in Singapore in this September 16, 2003 file photo. Kwa has died on October 2, 2010 at the age of 89, local media reported.

Singapore's Senior Minister Lee Kuan Yew (L), former prime minister and architect of modern Singapore, his wife Kwa Geok Choo (2nd L), his son Lee Hsien Loong (3rd L) and his daughter-in-law Ho Ching celebrate his 80th birthday in Singapore in this September 16, 2003 file photo. Kwa has died on October 2, 2010 at the age of 89, local media reported.

Kampfner, a Briton born in Singapore, had written about Singapore in his book, Freedom for Sale, available at the National Library.

“Why is it that so many people around the world appear willing to give up freedoms in return for either security and prosperity?” he asks and looks at life in Singapore, China, Russia, the United Arab Emirates, India, Italy, Britain and America.

The book, published this year, begins with the chapter, Singapore: Comfortable Model.

Here are excerpts from the chapter, starting with the first line:

“Singapore is quite simply the most successful society in the history of humanity.” I scratch my head and take a large gulp of my ice-cold water. I am sitting in the office of Professor Kishore Mahbubani, Singapore’s leading public intellectual, a man who travels the world telling doubters that countries can be harmonious and prosperous without succumbing to Western liberal democracy. Dean of the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy at the National University, Mahbubani is always a good person to visit to test the political temperature. He plays host to a stream of visitors from around the world. Before me a delegation of Chinese breezes past. After me comes the Swiss ambassador. They are all keen to learn the secret of the success of an island state that is both economic miracle and social test bed.

I am taken aback by the hubris of my host. But I am wary of being dismissive, of falling into the trap of the “Western mindset”, a term used to dismiss criticisms levelled by foreigners. For me it is

more than idle curiosity. I was born in Singapore, and although I left when I was young, my parents lived in the city-state for fifteen years… I have also kept up with a number of sons and daughters of my parents’ friends, some Indian. some Malay, most Chinese. They are established doctors, lawyers, financiers, musicians. They went to universities in Britain, the United States, or Australia, but most came back. They treat Singapore’s gleaming Changi airport as a bus stop, hopping on and off planes without thinking twice. In their day-to-day lives, they are able to do whatever they please. They enjoy their private freedoms, but free speech and political activism are things they express when they are abroad. I remember, as a student, going on demonstrations with several of my friends when they were in London. Back home, they button their lips. They can take it or leave it, they say. They do it out of choice.

The term “pact” was made for Singapore. The state’s per capita GDP is one of the highest in the world… In return, members of the citizenry avoid causing trouble. The city-state has become a monument to wealth creation… Everything works spectacularly well. The rich are exceedingly rich. The poor are exceedingly comfortable. The Singapore experiment has been conducted by Lee Kuan Yew, its prime minister for thirty years and supreme leader since relinquishing that office. Although Lee dominates the state, the Singapore pact is about much more than one man. It requires, and receives, the willing cooperation of the vast majority of the people…

In the course of 2008, Singapore became the first country to go into recession. Its reliance on exports had left it particularly vulnerable. But, in my sparring sessions at the National University and elsewhere, I saw little sign that the downturn was challenging the fundamental trade-off on which society is ordered, Mahbubani went further, arguing that Asia is better placed economically and politically to rebuild after the crisis. Asia, he said, is making progress towards its eventual goal of practising democracy more harmoniously than the West, largely because of its emphasis on

collectivist rather than individualist endeavour… The demands of the individual are subordinated to those of the collective, and yet the individual is free in most areas of life. Anyone with any talent is co-opted into the system. “Why are Brazilians best at football? They look in the barrios for six-year-old talent. We do the same with the state. We cherry-pick the best,” Mahbubani said. “If you think you can run something better, we give you the chance to prove it. We absorb dissent. The stupidest thing is to crush it. No brain is wasted. The political competence of our founding fathers was extraordinary. I find that very rarely in my travels around the world.” Mahbubani’s thesis, which he has set out in a recent book, has gone down well in Asia, less so in Europe and America. He was not surprised. “The West is becoming the problem,” he said. “You don’t want to give up the space. You’re also proving increasingly incompetent at government.” He concluded: “By every indicator Singapore is the most successful nation. It is not just the wealth we have created; it is how we take care of the people at the bottom of the pile.” …

At the Raffles Bar I spent an enjoyable evening with a senior newspaper executive… I asked my drinking partner at Raffles, if he saw any prospect of a softening of the defamation culture. No chance, he said. The law of contempt had been designed to protect public confidence in state institutions, in good times and bad. Most people in Singapore – citizens, people there on international business, representatives of foreign governments – had a vested interest in preserving the status quo. Why else, he suggested, would Singapore have done so well for so long?


Asian Defense News: Japan, US Agree to Enhance Military Cooperation

Thursday, 09 December 2010
Asian Defense News: U.S. and Japanese officials have agreed to increase regional military cooperation in wake of increased aggressive acts by North Korea.

The top U.S. military officer says he has "a real sense of urgency" about the need for Washington, Tokyo and Seoul to enhance security cooperation to deter North Korea.

A bombed out house island of Yeonpyeong that was struck by North Korean artillery, 30 Nov 2010

Photo: J. Strother

A bombed out house island of Yeonpyeong that was struck by North Korean artillery, 30 Nov 2010

Admiral Mike Mullen, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, made the comment after talks in Tokyo Thursday with Japanese defense officials. They agreed to increase security cooperation with South Korea.

Washington has held military maneuvers with its two key Asia allies and begun an intensive round of diplomacy since last month when North Korea shelled a South Korean island near a disputed maritime boundary.

Professor Hiro Katsumata at Tokyo's Waseda University says three-way military cooperation has quietly been going on since the mid-1990's when it emerged that North Korea likely possessed a nuclear bomb.

However, Katsumata contends the latest crisis does not mean that Tokyo, Seoul and Washington are forming a comprehensive, long-standing tripartite alliance.

"The only purpose of this partnership is to deal with the issue of North Korea," he said. "It is not a partnership to deal with the rise of China, not for terrorism, not for piracy/maritime security and certainly not for the promotion of democracy and so on."

The professor says, however, Japan needs a strong working relationship with South Korea - despite the historical animosity between the two.

"For Japan, partnership with South Korea is extremely important. Perhaps Japan needs South Korea more than South Korea needs Japan," added Katsumata. "When something happens on the Korean peninsula, one of the major tasks for the Japanese government is to evacuate the Japanese people. Many of them, businesspeople, work in Seoul and [elsewhere in] South Korea."

However, Japanese news reports quoted officials as saying it is premature to commit to military training with the United States and South Korea.

Japan has been reluctant to take part in multi-national military exercises not directly related to its defense. The constitution limits the use of its military if Japan is not under attack.

Admiral Mullen in Tokyo repeated earlier comments on China's responsibility to use its influence on North Korea.

Mullen said Northeast Asia is more volatile than it has been for much of the last half century, in great part due to the "reckless behavior of the North Korean regime, enabled by their friends in China."

North Korea's leader, Kim Jong Il held talks in Pyongyang on Thursday with a senior Chinese official. The North's official news agency says Dai Bingguo carried a message from the Chinese president.

Beijing wants emergency multi-national talks to defuse the tension. Washington, Seoul and Tokyo rejected the idea, saying Pyongyang should not be rewarded with negotiations for carrying out aggressive attacks.

North Korea, on Thursday repeated its contention that South Korea started the artillery fire last month. It says Pyongyang took action in response to the South firing "thousands of shells into the territorial waters" of North Korea. Seoul, however, says its troops fired guns on a training exercise within its territorial waters.

North Korea also is blamed for the sinking in March of a South Korean naval vessel. Pyongyang denies firing the torpedo that sank the Cheonan, killing 46 sailors.

A US Navy FA-18 Super Hornet is seen from a KC-135 air refuelling tanker during 'Keen Sword', US-Japan military exercise above the South China sea on December 9, 2010. Around 10,500 US service members and their Japanese Self Defence Forces counterparts participated in the eight-day-long exercise which started on Decomber 3.

A US Navy FA-18 Super Hornet is seen from a KC-135 air refuelling tanker during 'Keen Sword', US-Japan military exercise above the South China sea on December 9, 2010. Around 10,500 US service members and their Japanese Self Defence Forces counterparts participated in the eight-day-long exercise which started on Decomber 3

Asian Defense News: China's Top Diplomat Meets N. Korean Leader Amid Tensions

Thursday, 09 December 2010
Asian Defense News: China's official media say the nation's top diplomat has held "candid and in-depth" talks with North Korean leader Kim Jong Il.

Thursday's report by Xinhua news agency comes amid mounting pressure for China to rein in its North Korean ally. U.S. military chief of staff Mike Mullen renewed that message Thursday in Tokyo, where he urged Japan to join the United States and South Korea in facing any future North Korean aggression.

North Korean leader Kim Jong Il, center right, and Chinese State Councilor Dai Bingguo, center left, walk together in Pyongyang, North Korea, Dec. 9, 2010

Photo: AP

In this photo released by Korean Central News Agency via Korea News Service in Tokyo, North Korean leader Kim Jong Il, center right, and Chinese State Councilor Dai Bingguo, center left, walk together in Pyongyang, 9 Dec. 2010

Xinhua, in a brief report from the North Korean capital, said Kim and Chinese State Councilor Dai Bingguo "reached consensus on bilateral relations and the situation on the Korean peninsula." Hours earlier, U.S. Admiral Mike Mullen said that China must do more to lead North Korea away from the escalating threat of war.

Both North and South Korea have exchanged threats and staged artillery exercises since North Korean forces shelled a South Korean island last month, killing four people. A five-day South Korean exercise concludes on Friday.

Mullen was in Tokyo for talks with Japanese Chief of Staff Ryoichi Oriki and Defense Minister Toshimi Kitazawa. He told South Korean officials a day earlier that he hoped Japan would join them in planning and taking part in military exercises to answer any new North Korean attack.

Mullen also repeated the U.S. complaint that China has "enabled" North Korea's reckless behavior by failing to condemn it forcefully. He said China "must lead and guide North Korea to a better future."

North Korea meanwhile defended its November 23 attack on Yeonpyeong Island, which killed two soldiers and two civilians and destroyed 29 homes. In a report carried Thursday by its official news agency, the North said it had merely responded to a provocation by South Korea, saying the South had fired "thousands of shells into the territorial waters" of North Korea.

The attack came during artillery drills on Yeonpyeong, which lies near North Korea in waters claimed by both sides. The South says it had been firing artillery in a direction away from North Korean coast.

The U.S. military says Mullen's visit to Seoul on Wednesday was aimed in part at coordinating plans for a response to any new aggression from North Korea. Mullen stressed that the North must realize it cannot strike the South again with impunity, but that the response should not escalate the conflict. He said he would not object to the South responding to a North Korean attack with air strikes.

In the United States on Wednesday, former ambassador to the United Nations Bill Richardson announced he will travel to North Korea next week to help ease tensions. Richardson, who now serves as governor of the state of New Mexico and has visited Pyongyang several times, said he will travel at the invitation of the North Korean government.

North Korean leader Kim Jong-il (C) and Chinese State Councillor Dai Bingguo (3rd L, front) walk for their talks in Pyongyang in this picture released by the North's official KCNA news agency December 9, 2010.
North Korean leader Kim Jong-il (C) and Chinese State Councillor Dai Bingguo (3rd L, front) walk for their talks in Pyongyang in this picture released by the North's official KCNA news agency December 9, 2010.

Asian Defense News: Philippines to sign deal for military equipment

Asian Defense News: The Philippines said yesterday it was set to sign a "substantial" deal to buy military equipment from China, but insisted it should not impact on its close ties with the United States.

The logistics deal was to be signed in Beijing by Philippine armed forces chief General Ricardo David.

The visit was aimed at "building bridges of goodwill" and to boost defence relations between the Asian nations, Philippine military spokesman Brigadier General Jose Mabanta said.

"It would formalise the very good relationship between our countries in terms of exchange of logistics, which the Philippines will be greatly benefiting from," he said.

Although details of the deal were not available, Mabanta described its benefits as "very substantial" for the 130,000-strong Philippine force. He said it would beef up the ill-equipped and often cash-strapped military, which despite US assistance has not been able to crush decades-long communist and Muslim separatist rebellions.

Mabanta emphasised the planned deal did not signify a shift in military alliances, stressing that the Philippines valued Washington's continued help against al-Qaeda-linked militants on the country's main southern island. "There are no political implications," he said.

Hundreds of US troops have been stationed in the southern Philippines since early 2002, helping to train their Filipino counterparts in how to combat the Abu Sayyaf militants.

The Philippines is also a former US colony and remains one of the United States' closest allies in Asia.

The US has previously expressed concern over China's growing military and economic muscle in the region, mostly by ploughing millions of dollars in investments and assistance to its weaker neighbours.

When asked if the logistics deal was to buy military equipment from China, Mabanta said he was not sure.

However, the Philippine military said previously that China last month gave it 33 pieces of heavy equipment, such as bulldozers, worth about 172 million pesos (HK$30.4 million).

The army used the equipment to build roads and bridges to bring outreach programmes to remote areas where Maoist New People's Army (NPA) rebels operate, as well as in rehabilitation efforts in places that had been hit by natural disasters.

The NPA is the armed unit of the Communist Party of the Philippines, whose rebellion that began in 1969 was initially supported by Beijing.

Mabanta said yesterday China had cut ties with the NPA long ago and was now focused on helping improve the Philippine army.

This file photo taken on July 2, 2010 shows Philippine soldiers marching during a parade at the handover ceremony for the new military's chief of staff, attended by President Aquino (not pictured) at the military headquarters in Manila. The Philippines said Decmber 7, 2010 it was set to sign a 'substantial' deal to buy military equipment from China, but insisted it should not impact on its close ties with the United States.

This file photo taken on July 2, 2010 shows Philippine soldiers marching during a parade at the handover ceremony for the new military's chief of staff, attended by President Aquino (not pictured) at the military headquarters in Manila. The Philippines said Decmber 7, 2010 it was set to sign a 'substantial' deal to buy military equipment from China, but insisted it should not impact on its close ties with the United States.

Asian Defense News: Afghan War Officer-Training Program Lags, but Makes Progress

Under the “Afghanistan-Pakistan Hands” program, a pool of military officers receives about five months of specialized training and signs on for multiple tours, not just in combat roles but in governance, economic development and security training.

The effort was devised as an answer to criticism that the war effort essentially started from scratch every year with the arrival of each fresh rotation of officers. Intensive training in local languages is the heart of the program, along with courses in culture, politics and history.

But the effort suffered initially from a lack of volunteers and reluctant support from some corners of the military. Since then, the military has begun to offer career-building incentives to those who sign up, and to improve oversight over the project.

Adm. Mike Mullen, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, who a year ago wrote a stern memorandum rebuking the four armed services for not sending their best officers to a program he strongly supported, gave a somewhat more positive assessment when asked for an update.

“No really good initiative stays good without some work and some growing pains,” he said in a statement. “Afghan Hands is no exception. But that’s the important thing to remember about it. It’s growing and it’s getting more viable and valuable every day.”

His criticism last year made clear to the military service chiefs that it was their responsibility to make certain that officers would find their chances for promotion enhanced, and not hurt, by committing to the unconventional career path.

To that end, the Army has instituted incentives for officers who choose the program: They will receive preferential consideration for assignments commanding battalions and brigades in Afghanistan. Another complaint heard from officers in the first group sent to Afghanistan was that local commanders would assign them to the crisis of the day, and not to a position tailored to their specialized training. An assignments cell has been set up in Afghanistan to better place new arrivals in the field, officials said.

The personnel target for the program is 750 people — the vast majority in Afghanistan — and the program is not quite halfway there, with 161 officers deployed; in addition, 186 are in training that includes learning the Dari, Pashto or Urdu languages, and a third wave await training.

When members finish their tours in the region, they will be assigned to positions that deal directly with issues in Afghanistan and Pakistan, in the Pentagon, at Central Command or elsewhere. They will rotate out to the war zone on their next assignment.

KABUL, AFGHANISTAN - DECEMBER 08:  U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates (C) is escorted by Col. Arthur Kandarian after arriving at Forward Operating Base Howz-E-Madad in Kandahar Province December 8, 2010 in Afghanistan. Gates is visiting U.S. soldiers in different operational areas of Afghanistan during his visit.

KABUL, AFGHANISTAN - DECEMBER 08: U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates (C) is escorted by Col. Arthur Kandarian after arriving at Forward Operating Base Howz-E-Madad in Kandahar Province December 8, 2010 in Afghanistan. Gates is visiting U.S. soldiers in different operational areas of Afghanistan during his visit.

Asian Defense News: Navy retires INS Vagli, India down to 14 subs

Asian Defense News: NEW DELHI: The last of India's Foxtrot-class submarines, INS Vagli , will retire after 36 years of operational service on Thursday. But the well-deserved nostalgia over INS Vagli's yeoman service should come with a harsh reality check.

India is now down to just 14 ageing submarines, with only eight to nine operational at any given time. It will get progressively worse. By the time Navy gets the first of the six Scorpene submarines being built at Mazagon Docks in 2015 — the Rs 23,562-crore project is already running three years behind schedule — only 10 submarines will be operational.

Latest projections, in fact, show India will have only five of the existing 10 Russian Kilo-class and four German HDW submarines by 2020. And only two by 2022.

Even if the six Scorpenes manage to roll out between 2015 and 2020, as is now expected, India will have a grand total of just eight to nine diesel-electric submarines by 2022.

This when the requirement is for at least 18 conventional submarines, with both China and Pakistan rapidly bolstering their underwater combat capabilities.

It, once again, underlines India's sheer lack of long-term strategic planning to systematically build military capabilities in tune with geo-political objectives, despite big bucks being spent on defence acquisitions in recent years.

Vela class submarines of the Indian Navy were variants of the Soviet Foxtrot class submarines.
The last Vela Class will decommission in 2011.

The Foxtrot class was the NATO reporting name of a class of diesel-electric patrol submarines that were built in the Soviet Union. The Soviet designation of this class was Project 641.

The Foxtrot class was designed to replace the earlier Zulu class, which suffered from structural weaknesses and harmonic vibration problems that limited its operational depth and submerged speed. The first Foxtrot was laid down in 1957 and commissioned in 1958 and the last was completed in 1983. A total of 58 were built for the Soviet Navy at the Sudomekh division of the Admiralty Shipyard (now Admiralty Wharves), St. Petersburg. 8 were built for the Indian Navy. Additional hulls were built for other countries.

Asian Defense News: Pak urged US to help end Indian interference in Balochistan

Asian Defense News: Pak urged US to help end Indian interference in Balochistan
By Anwar Iqbal
gilani kerry 543 Pak urged US to help end Indian interference in Balochistan

WikiLeaks has released the details of Feb 16, 2010 meeting between PM Gilani and Senator John Kerry.—AP photo

WASHINGTON: In a meeting with a key US lawmaker earlier this year, Prime Minister Yousuf Raza Gilani insisted that in order to gain Pakistans trust India would needed to decrease its footprint in Afghanistan and stop interfering in Balochistan.

Details of the Feb 16 meeting between the prime minister and chairman of the US Senate Committee on Foreign Relations, Senator John Kerry, were leaked recently by the whistle-blowers’ website, WikiLeaks.

The cable, sent by the then US ambassador Anne W. Patterson to the State Department in Washington, noted that the meeting focussed on the state of India-Pakistani relations.

The prime minister told the American lawmaker that Pakistan was sincere in its efforts to improve relations with India and pointed to recent meetings between the foreign secretaries as evidence of its sincerity.

He noted that Pakistan and India had also resumed backchannel discussions. Mr Gilani said that improving bilateral relations with India was in Pakistans best interest as it would enable Pakistan to focus all of its attention on securing its western border.

Mr Gilani, however, noted that in order to gain public support for this process, the US had to “treat India and Pakistan equally”.

He added that “India will need to gain Pakistan’s trust and indicated that reducing the Indian footprint in Afghanistan and halting Indian support of militants in Balochistan would be steps in the right direction”.

Senator Kerry noted that talks between the foreign secretaries had “enormous potential” and urged Pakistan not to allow pressure from the local media and the masses to “derail these efforts”.

Senator Kerry argued that dialogue with India was an opportunity to “create new security arrangements that could change the regional dynamic”.

While assuring Mr Gilani that the effort would not be US-driven, Senator Kerry indicated that the US government was open to the idea of serving as a mediator to help facilitate the resumption of the Pakistan-India Composite Dialogue.

Noting that Indias politicians were currently focussed on counterterrorism, Senator Kerry suggested that Pakistan present India government with its plan to tackle terrorism.

He said that this would be a clear “confidence builder” that would make India more willing to move forward in talks about Kashmir and water disputes.

Prime Minister Gilani agreed to present Senator Kerry’s proposal to other Pakistani leaders. He was amenable to the idea of a rapprochement with India, but expressed concern that the public would not support the idea.

Senator Kerry said that in order to gain public support for this initiative, the government of Pakistan needed to clearly outline the long-term economic benefits of improved bilateral relations, such as an improvement in social development and increased investments and trade, to the Pakistani people.

The prime minister said Pakistan was committed to fighting extremism and pointed to the recent success of the military operations in Swat, Malakand and Waziristan as evidence of such.

Senator Kerry said the US government had a great respect and deep understanding of the difficulties involved in waging this war.

He praised Pakistan for the military’s efforts, acknowledged the difference that it was making, and thanked Mr Gilani for the sacrifices that Pakistani troops were making every day.

The prime minister complained that the large number of Afghan refugees living in Pakistan were destabilising the western provinces and contributing to extremism.

Mr Gilani suggested that the construction of new refugee camps in Afghanistan would dramatically improve Pakistan’s security situation by halting the more than 45,000 Afghans who move across the Afghanistan-Pakistan border each day.

Mr Gilani also explained that capacity building for law enforcement agencies, the military and the police was an essential part of continuing the fight against extremism.

He said the government of Pakistan had recently provided $8 million to support capacity building initiatives for the Frontier Corps and law enforcement in NWFP.

Mr Gilani expressed frustration at Pakistans inability to provide more money to support this activity due to budgetary constraints.

He attributed these constraints to the delayed disbursement of Coalition Support Funds, and the fact that recent pledges from the Friends of Democratic Pakistan member countries had yet to materialize.

Mr Gilani urged the US government to disburse CSF funds as soon as possible.

A policeman surveys a vehicle which was destroyed in a suicide bomb attack in Kohat, located in Pakistan's northwest Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa Province December 8, 2010. A suicide bomber blew himself up beside the minibus in northwest Pakistan on Wednesday, killing at least 16 people, officials said.

A policeman surveys a vehicle which was destroyed in a suicide bomb attack in Kohat, located in Pakistan's northwest Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa Province December 8, 2010. A suicide bomber blew himself up beside the minibus in northwest Pakistan on Wednesday, killing at least 16 people, officials said.